As it appeared on "American Song Contest (Episode 5)"



Dear Natalie, let me guess he's still mad at me
Probably saying that I lied, that I am crazy, I'm off the deep end
Did you ever think maybe he seemed a little too shady?


Cause he said forever I'm yours
But he probably said it to me, to you and to her
It started all so good with every word he swore he would
But I was never the only one, and I'm sure I could never be a Natalie.


Oh, when told me, do you still wear that dress you like?
The one you wore on that Friday night?
When you were talking, I was watching
and crying in the corner
But it didn't matter


Cause he said forever I'm yours
But he probably said it to me, to you and to her
It started all so good with every word he swore he would
But I was never the only one, and I'm sure I could never be a Natalie.


Oh, Natalie, I still lie awake from his apathy
How he dare to have the audacity to hold my hand?
Wreckening your plans?
But did you ever think maybe I'm not the girl that he made me?


Cause he said forever I'm yours
But he probably said it to me, to you and to her
It started all so good with every word he swore he would
But I was never the only one, and I'm sure I could never be a Natalie.
(Natalie, I could never be)

LYRICS FROM OTHER ARTISTS